Saturday, July 18, 2015

Logic and Fallacy

"When I use a word," Humpty Dumpty said in a rather scornful tone, "it means exactly what I choose it to mean--neither more nor less." "The question is," said Alice, "whether you can make words mean so many different things." The question is," said Humpty Dumpty, "which is to be master--that's all."

-- Lewis Carroll, "Through the Looking Glass"

From the time of the Greeks until the last century or so, the most important study for a citizen was Rhetoric: The science of persuading others, using language and gesture. Rhetoric is central to political discourse. In no small part because a rhetorical statement can be both logical and a lie, and so be very powerful. We are persuaded by the logical structure, but assume the speaker is using the words to mean what we would mean. Sometimes we're right. Sometimes we're not. Most of the time we can't tell, even if we're nodding our heads because it sounds right. The problem is that something can sound logical and not be Logical. Logic should be solid, like a building. But it's a house made of words and grammar, squishy things than can change shape in a flash. Math may be solid; language not at all. Humpty's master is the one who uses the disconnect of language from logic to advance his (or her) own purposes. Tyrants large and small know that. As an individual, our only defense against such a master is to know enough about logic and rhetoric to call "bullshit." As a community, the best defense is to foster an open critique of ALL political speech and to hold speakers accountable (not necessarily punishable). Fallacies come in many forms. A Formal Fallacy is a breakdown in the logical form of the argument: the conclusion does not follow from the premises. An education in formal logic is useful in identifying these fallacies (or a visit to Wikipedia). Informal Fallacies involve the content--the words--of the argument, and are probably what we should be mostly aware of. These include:

Arguing from ignorance (if I don't know then it must not be important), Begging the question (stating the desired conclusion as a premise), Correlation proving causation, Ecological fallacies (a member of a group must be just like the group), Ad hominem arguments, False equivalences, Fallacies of the single cause, Etc., etc.

While watching the news tonight, see how many logical fallacies you can identify, not by the formal name of the fallacy, but by the way words are used to divert us from what is really going on. For example, from a blog post I saw today:
Senator Lindsey Graham, "Everything I learned about Iranians I learned working in the pool room  [as a teenager]," he said. "I met a lot of liars, and I know Iranians are liars."
Clearly, the conclusion (Iranis are liars) does not follow from the statement (I met a lot of liars in the poolroom), even if he'd used a more logical middle statement (I met Iranis who were liars). The clear illogic did not, however, keep him from saying it as if it were persuasive. And that's the key. After all, according to Humpty, the only question is: who is the actual  master (of the message)? Sometimes it's the king. Sometimes it's the fool. Sometimes its the Senator.    

Friday, July 17, 2015

need your reply

Hello,

I have mailed you a couple of times already but it seems there's a problem
because I haven't heard back from you.
We offer email marketing and we can generate you more business sales and
leads.

Please reply today so we can go over options for you.

Best regards,
Joe
Contact: mrviron@sina.com

Quick Question

Hello,

I have mailed you a couple of times already but it seems there's a problem
because I haven't heard back from you.
We offer email marketing and we can generate you more business sales and
leads.

Please reply today so we can go over options for you.

Best regards,
Joe
Contact: mrviron@sina.com

eLearning Course - Everything You Need to Know About ..Negotiation

Written by a practitioner, you will get your investment back many times
over.

Go to www.procurementbusinessskills.com and www.practicalbusinessskills.com
50% discount.


B. Hughes MSc MCIPS

[M] +44 0746-222-7806

[W] www.procurementbusinessskills.com

[E] xlltimes@tom.com

eLearning Course - Everything You Need to Know About....Negotiation

Written by a practitioner, you will get your investment back many times
over.

Go to www.procurementbusinessskills.com and www.practicalbusinessskills.com
50% discount.
If not entirely satisfied guaranteed money back.


B. Hughes MSc MCIPS

[M] 0746-222-7806

[W] www.procurementlbusinessskills.com

[E] xlltimes@tom.com

Wednesday, July 15, 2015

Quick Question

Hello,

I work for a leading digital marketing agency in Southern California that
focuses on helping small businesses advertise online.

Our full service small business agency offers the following services and
products:

1. Geography-Targeted Digital Advertising in the area(s) of your choice

2. High-End Website Design and Development

3. Banner Ads, Mobile Advertising

4. Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

5. Search Engine Advertising

6. E-Commerce Solutions, iPhone, Android Apps Development.

If you are interested, I would be more than happy to reach out with more
information
and develop a plan that works with your business type.

PROFESSIONAL TRUSTWORTHY RELIABLE QUALITY SERVICE

Thanks & Regards,

Zach
Business Development Manager
Contact: maymay01@aliyun.com

Tuesday, July 14, 2015

worrying about business sales?

Hey,

We want to help you to grow business fast.
We offer email marketing services and we can generate you more business and
leads.
We only look long term cooperation which can grow your business sales 2-4
times than what it is now.

Please reply today so i can go over options for you.

Thanks,
Jonathan
Contact: yyangk@tom.com

Have you checked this?

Hi,

Are you interested in purchasing LOGO promotional and marketing products
for your company?

We produce branded USB Drives with your Logo or Artwork printed to be used
for marketing or as gifts.

There is more info on our website: www.customprintedflashdrives.com

We can pre-load your media files, images, presentations and files onto the
drives for you.
People will keep the USB drive you give them and show it to others
increasing your marketing value.

Please click www.customprintedflashdrives.com to see all of our stock
models and get a quote.

If you are nonprofit, we have further discounts for schools and charities.

Thanks,
David
USB Drive Specialist
Contact: yabein@tom.com

Wednesday, July 8, 2015

is business slow?

Hey,

We can help you to grow business fast.
We provide target email marketing services and can generate you more
business and leads.
We are looking for long term cooperation which can increase your business
sales 2-4 times than now.

Please reply back so i can go over options for you.

Thanks,
Roy
Contact: soul2929@tom.com

interested in growing sales?

Hey,

We can help you to grow business fast.
We provide target email marketing services and can generate you more
business and leads.
We are looking for long term cooperation which can increase your business
sales 2-4 times than now.

Please reply back so i can go over options for you.

Thanks,
Roy
Contact: soul2929@tom.com

Tuesday, July 7, 2015

USB Drives with your Logo

Hi,

Are you interested in purchasing LOGO promotional and marketing products
for your company?
We produce branded USB Drives with your Logo or Artwork printed to be used
for marketing or as gifts.

There is more info on our website: www.logousbflashdrives.net
We can pre-load your media files, images, presentations and files onto the
drives for you.

People will keep the USB drive you give them and show it to others
increasing your marketing value.
Please click www.logousbflashdrives.net to see all of our stock models and
get a quote.

If you are nonprofit, we have further discounts for schools and charities.

Thanks,
David
USB Drive Specialist
Email: duyaersi@aliyun.com

is business slow?

Hey,

We can help you to grow business fast.
We provide target email marketing services and can generate you more
business and leads.
We are looking for long term cooperation which can increase your business
sales 2-4 times than now.

Please reply back so i can go over options for you.

Thanks,
Roy
Contact: soul2929@tom.com

Monday, July 6, 2015

need to get more customers?

Hey,

Is business slow? We can help
We specialize in providing target email marketing services to a number of
businesses all over the world!

We would like to be your marketing partners and help your business reach
the new level.
Let's increase your business sales 2-4 times than now.

Please contact us today so I can go over options for you.

Thanks,
Peter Strong
Contact: vancans@sina.com

Friday, July 3, 2015

Business slow? We can help

Hey,

Is business slow? We can help
You are receiving this email because we wish you to use our target email
marketing service.
We specialize in providing target email marketing services to a number of
businesses all over the world!
We can generate you more business and leads from our email marketing
solutions.

We would like to be your marketing partners and help your business reach
the new level.
Let's increase your business sales 2-4 times than now.

Please contact us today so I can go over options for you.

Thanks,
Jason North
Contact: vancans@sina.com

Wednesday, July 1, 2015

private investors

We are private investors and certified loan lender.

We do offer financing ranging from personal to corporate finance to
interested persons or companies who are seeking for financial assistance
(loan) at a negotiable interest rates of 3%.

Kindly contact us for further details by providing the followings below.
Name in Full:
Amount Needed As Loan:
Duration/Period of Loan:
Contact Address:
Country of Residence:
Direct Phone Number:

Regards,
Mark
NACROD FINANCE
Contact: balancenew@aliyun.com